Decision guide
Refinish vs. replace cabinets
Most kitchens don't need $25,000 in new cabinetry — they need new doors, new hardware, and a fresh finish. But sometimes the bones aren't worth saving. Here's how to tell the difference.
Side by side
| Refinish | Replace | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical cost | $2,000–$5,000 | $10,000–$30,000+ |
| Disruption | Kitchen back in use within days | 1–3 weeks of demo and install |
| Look & feel | Updated finish on your existing layout | New doors, drawers, and possible layout changes |
| Lifespan after work | 10–15 years if the boxes are solid | 20–30+ years |
Contractor's perspective
Our honest take
If the cabinet boxes are structurally sound — no water damage, no warping, drawers that still close right — refinishing is smart money. We see homeowners spend $20,000 more than they need to because they assumed replace was the only option. That said, if the layout doesn't work for you, if you want to add an island, or if the boxes are shot, replacement is worth every dollar.
Choose Refinish when
The cabinet boxes are solid, the layout already works, you want a quick refresh, or budget is the main constraint.
Choose Replace when
Boxes show water damage or warping, you want a different layout, it's a full kitchen remodel anyway, or you're doing a forever-home renovation.
Real example
We installed new white shaker cabinetry here as part of a full kitchen renovation — the right call because the old layout was being reconfigured entirely.
See the Clementine Cottage case study →Not sure which way to go?
Tell us about your space and what you're weighing. We'll give you a straight answer and a quote — no sales pitch.